You have clearly never been in that situation then. It is obviously not like this for many people, but for students for example, it often means a lot more
While I don’t fully share the notion and tone of other commenter, I gotta say LLMs have absolutely tanked education and science, as noted by many and as I witnessed firsthand.
I’m a young scientist on my way to PhD, and I get to assist in a microbiology course for undergraduates.
The amount of AI slop coming from student assignments is astounding, and worse of all - they don’t see it themselves. When it comes to me checking their actual knowledge, it’s devastating.
And it’s not just undergrads - many scientific articles also now have signs of AI slop, which messes up with research to a concerning degree.
Personally, I tried using more specialized tools like Perplexity in Research mode to look for sources, but it royally messed up listing the sources - it took actual info from scientific articles, but then referenced entirely different articles that hold no relation to it.
So, in my experience LLMs can be useful to generate a simple text or help you tie known facts together. But as a learning tool…be careful, or rather just don’t use them for that. Classical education exists for a good reason, and it is that you learn to get factually correct and relevant information, analyze it and keep it in your head for future reference. It takes more time, but is ultimately much worth it.
Sure, many don’t care and I have also experienced this, but it’s a fabulous way to quickly get a glimpse at a subject, or to get started, or to learn more. It’s not always correct, but for known subjects it’s pretty good
Anything related to law or really specific subjects will be horrible though
Classical education exists for a good reason
Sure, but not everyone teaches well enough, and LLMs are one of the ways to balance this, kinda
And if you don’t understand then… yea it’s still useful as a way to avoid failing a year which is morally questionable but hey, another topic
Alright, we generally seem to be on the same page :)
(Except numerous great books and helpful short materials exist for virtually any popular major, and, while they take longer to study, they provide order of magnitude better knowledge)
And I already pointed the upside. You don’t have to use the default UI though, custom UI exists, APIs exists, and you don’t have to enter personal infos in prompts, as well as use your residential IP… this pretty much makes it unlinkable to you
To use your analogy, it’s like someone said, “Well, if you want a Michelin 5-star steak au jus, then your wallet is gonna take a hit”. And you replied, “That’s like saying in order to eat dinner you need to raise your own livestock and train for years as a professional chef”.
I’m not saying corporate LLMs are bad, or that they have no upside. I’m saying your scale for what’s essential and what’s a luxury is alarming.
You have clearly never been in that situation then. It is obviously not like this for many people, but for students for example, it often means a lot more
While I don’t fully share the notion and tone of other commenter, I gotta say LLMs have absolutely tanked education and science, as noted by many and as I witnessed firsthand.
I’m a young scientist on my way to PhD, and I get to assist in a microbiology course for undergraduates.
The amount of AI slop coming from student assignments is astounding, and worse of all - they don’t see it themselves. When it comes to me checking their actual knowledge, it’s devastating.
And it’s not just undergrads - many scientific articles also now have signs of AI slop, which messes up with research to a concerning degree.
Personally, I tried using more specialized tools like Perplexity in Research mode to look for sources, but it royally messed up listing the sources - it took actual info from scientific articles, but then referenced entirely different articles that hold no relation to it.
So, in my experience LLMs can be useful to generate a simple text or help you tie known facts together. But as a learning tool…be careful, or rather just don’t use them for that. Classical education exists for a good reason, and it is that you learn to get factually correct and relevant information, analyze it and keep it in your head for future reference. It takes more time, but is ultimately much worth it.
Sure, many don’t care and I have also experienced this, but it’s a fabulous way to quickly get a glimpse at a subject, or to get started, or to learn more. It’s not always correct, but for known subjects it’s pretty good
Anything related to law or really specific subjects will be horrible though
Sure, but not everyone teaches well enough, and LLMs are one of the ways to balance this, kinda
And if you don’t understand then… yea it’s still useful as a way to avoid failing a year which is morally questionable but hey, another topic
Alright, we generally seem to be on the same page :)
(Except numerous great books and helpful short materials exist for virtually any popular major, and, while they take longer to study, they provide order of magnitude better knowledge)
Yeah, this thing that’s notorious for hallucinating and has only recently become even somewhat reliable is essential.
How did all those students from 2021 even survive??
Jesus, we’re absolutely fucked.
Surviving is different than living in good conditions
As with every tool, it has downsides. Learn to use it or continue to whine
That is… literally my point.
You’re comparing very disparate things. And I already pointed out the downside. No one here is whining about anything.
And I already pointed the upside. You don’t have to use the default UI though, custom UI exists, APIs exists, and you don’t have to enter personal infos in prompts, as well as use your residential IP… this pretty much makes it unlinkable to you
To use your analogy, it’s like someone said, “Well, if you want a Michelin 5-star steak au jus, then your wallet is gonna take a hit”. And you replied, “That’s like saying in order to eat dinner you need to raise your own livestock and train for years as a professional chef”.
I’m not saying corporate LLMs are bad, or that they have no upside. I’m saying your scale for what’s essential and what’s a luxury is alarming.
I wish they were always a luxury, but in some situations they’re just too important to me